menu hero image

Pact for the Future directs states to advance discussions on killer robots with urgency

States must now support all efforts towards international cooperation to address the risks posed by autonomous weapons systems

On Sunday 22 September 2024, the ‘Pact for the Future‘ was adopted by world leaders at the opening plenary of the Summit of the Future at the United Nations Headquarters in New York.  

The Summit of the Future was positioned by the UN Secretary-General as a once-in-a-generation opportunity to chart a new course for international cooperation in response to emerging threats and “bring multilateralism back from the brink”. As the outcome document for the Summit, the Pact for the Future aimed to provide an ambitious, action-oriented vision for a more peaceful world, and was developed through months of negotiations and consultations between states to find consensus. 

Despite a last minute attempt from the floor by seven states led by Russia to criticise the Pact for a lack of consensus and introduce an amendment to the resolution, which would have introduced new language stating that “the UN system shall not intervene in matters which are essentially within the domestic jurisdiction of any State”, the Pact for the Future was adopted by member states without a vote.  

Stop Killer Robots welcomes the reference to autonomous weapons systems in the Pact for the Future and the direction for states to “advance with urgency discussions” – a demonstration that killer robots are considered a global challenge for humanity and addressing the risks they raise is a priority for the international community.

 

 

However, it is disappointing that the outcome text is significantly weaker than earlier drafts, following push-back on this section by a tiny minority of states, including Russia, India, the UK, and the US, during the five revisions of the Pact. As adopted, the Pact for the Future fails to identify the risks posed by autonomous weapons, and does not reflect the views of the majority of states that a legally binding instrument on autonomous weapons systems is urgently needed.

As laid out in the Pact, we urge member states of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons (CCW) Group of Governmental Experts on lethal autonomous weapons systems (GGE LAWS) to fulfil their mandate to develop an instrument on autonomous weapons systems and complete the work of the Group “as soon as possible, preferably before the end of 2025”, as decided in the 2023 final report of the Meeting of the High Contracting Parties of the CCW. To appropriately respond to the challenges to international law posed by autonomy in weapons systems, this instrument must be legally binding and create prohibitions and regulations to ensure meaningful human control over the use of force.

In his remarks to the opening plenary of the Summit following the adoption of the Pact, the UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres said

New technologies, including AI, are being developed in a moral and legal vacuum, without governance or guardrails. In short, our multilateral tools and institutions are unable to respond effectively to today’s political, economic, environmental and technological challenges.

He continued to say that the Pact for the Future recognises “the changing nature of conflict” and commits to steps to “govern the use of lethal autonomous weapons.” 

We are at a critical point. It is clear that negotiating new international law on autonomous weapons systems is now more urgent than ever before. The UN Secretary-General and the International Committee of the Red Cross have issued a joint appeal to states to negotiate new law by 2026. It is essential to meet this deadline. As set out in the recent report on autonomous weapons systems from the UN Secretary-General, mandated by last year’s historic UNGA Resolution 78/241, autonomous weapons systems are a critical issue facing humanity and time is running out to take preventive action. The international community must start drawing lines for humanity through international law, now, and launch negotiations on a legally binding instrument on autonomous weapons systems, to prevent the automation of killing. 

Turning towards the opening of the UNGA and First Committee, all states that have recognised that autonomous weapons systems raise profound legal, ethical and humanitarian concerns must support all efforts to advance work and expand discussions on this issue, and undertake negotiations in a forum that is open to all states and civil society, and where progress cannot be blocked.

Isabelle Jones

Image alt text
SKR dots icon

Stop killer robots

Join us

Keep up with the latest developments in the movement to Stop Killer Robots.

Join us